I N T H E H I GH CO U RT O F U T T A RA K H A N D
A T N A I N I T A L
H ON ’ B LE TH E CH I EF JUSTI CE M S. RI TU B A H RI
A N D
H ON ’ B LE M R. JUSTI CE RA K ESH TH A PLI YA L
W RI T PETI TI ON ( PI L) N O. 1 1 1 OF 2 0 2 4
TH
2 8 JU N E, 2 0 2 4
Kalim ulla Khan …… Pet it ioner
Ver sus
St at e of Ut t ar ak hand & ot her s …… Respondent s
Counsel for t he pet it ioner : Mr . S.S. Yadav , lear ned counsel
Counsel for t he r espondent s : Mr . Am ar endr a Pr at ap Singh,
lear ned Addit ional Adv ocat e
Gener al for t he St at e / r espondent
Nos. 1, 4 & 5
: Mr . Rahul Consul, lear ned counsel
for r espondent Nos. 2, 3, 6 & 7
T h e Co u r t m a d e t h e f o l l o w i n g :
JU D GM EN T:
( p er H o n ’b l e Th e Ch i ef Ju st i ce M s. Ri t u Ba h r i )
Th e pet it ion er , w h o claim s h im self t o be a
social act iv ist an d pu blic spir it ed per son , h as pr ef er r ed
t h e pr esen t w r it pet it ion seek in g dir ect ion t o r espon den t
Nos. 1 t o 5 t o r est r ain t h e r espon den t Nos. 6 an d 7 f r om
r aisin g con st r u ct ion of com m u n it y Hall in t h e par k at
Asim a Vih ar Colon y , sit u at ed at Village Siv ala Kh u r d,
Dist r ict Deh r adu n .
2
2 ) Th e pet it ion er is n eit h er a r esiden t of Asim a
Vih ar Colon y , n or a m em ber of t h e Cooper at iv e Hou sin g
Societ y . Accor din g t o t h e cou n sel f or r espon den t Nos. 2 ,
3 , 6 an d 7 , as per lay ou t plan t h e lan d in qu est ion w as
m ean t f or com m u n it y pu r poses, an d t h e pet it ion er is n ot
ev en a r esiden t m em ber of t h e co- oper at iv e h ou sin g
societ y .
3 ) I n su ch v iew of t h e m at t er , t h e w r it pet it ion is
dism issed w it h cost qu an t if ied at r u pees t w en t y
t h ou san d t o be paid by t h e pet it ion er t o t h e High Cou r t
Legal Ser v ices Au t h or it y at Nain t ial, w it h in a per iod of
f if t een day s f r om t oday .
4 ) Pen din g applicat ion , if an y , also st an ds
disposed of .
_______________
RI TU B A H RI , C. J.
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
RA K ESH TH A PL I YA L , J.
TH
Dt : 28 JUNE, 2024
Negi